MAAT INDEX
Themes

Retail media and advertising monetization

17 statements on the record across 3 companies, ordered by how much each has said. Every quote is verbatim from its call.

THE FIFTEEN-SECOND READ

Retail media across COST, LOW and TGT is uniformly framed as an early stage but expanding profit lever. COST's Millerchip called its first targeted CPG campaign a two to three times ROAS success, scaled from one off-site campaign to roughly ten partner campaigns by Q1 fiscal 2025, and still described the effort as very early stage by September 2025, with over 25 suppliers awaiting the next wave [m3115, m3114, m3116, m3206, m3217, m3402, m3412]. Vachris flagged that member benefit criteria remain undetermined, underscoring COST's member value reinvestment approach as distinct from peers [m3126, m3217]. LOW is rebranding its retail media network into a simplified platform focused on shelf performance, launches, seasonal promotions and multiproduct sales [m3241]. TGT has set the most concrete targets, with Cornell guiding Roundel to high teens 2024 growth after 20% in 2023, Sylvester aiming to double Roundel's roughly $2 billion value in five years, and Gomez targeting $5 billion Target Plus GMV by 2030, with both units posting double digit Q1 2025 growth [m3542, m3330, m3541, m3543, m3677, m3678, m3670].

COST8TGT8LOW1
COST8 statements

Millerchip said Costco completed its first targeted media campaign with a large CPG partner, achieving two to three times the typical expected return on ad spend, and called retail media early innings but a significant future growth opportunity. [m3115, m3114] Millerchip noted over 25 suppliers were eager to join the next wave of off-site campaigns, while Vachris said member benefit criteria for retail media were still to be determined. [m3116, m3126] By Q1 fiscal 2025, Millerchip said the first off-site campaign had expanded into additional similar campaigns with roughly ten different partners, and described a member value reinvestment approach distinct from peers. [m3206, m3217] By September 2025, Millerchip tied digital capabilities to enabling more targeted retail media ads while still calling the effort very much in early stages within a broader alternative revenue view. [m3402, m3412]

Show the 8 verbatim statements
#m3115 · 2024-12-12 · Gary Millerchip · STATED

This quarter, we completed our first targeted media campaign through third-party media channels with one of our largest CPG partners. The campaign achieved two to three times the return on ad spend typically expected, highlighting the value we can create for our members and suppliers.

#m3114 · 2024-12-12 · Gary Millerchip · STATED

To use a baseball analogy, we are very much in the early innings with retail media. But we continue to believe this represents a significant growth opportunity in the future.

#m3116 · 2024-12-12 · Gary Millerchip · STATED

Our retail media team is now working with over 25 suppliers who are eager to participate in our next wave of off-site campaigns.

#m3126 · 2024-12-12 · Ron Vachris · STATED

That and that again is, as Gary mentioned earlier, we're in the early stages and we're gonna look at where we feel the benefits will be to our members. So that is to be determined yet.

#m3206 · 2025-03-06 · Gary Millerchip · STATED

On retail media, following our first off-site retail media campaign in Q1, we have entered into a number of additional similar campaigns with roughly ten different partners.

#m3217 · 2025-03-06 · Gary Millerchip · STATED

We'll think of it very much as being, how do we generate our share of that value so we can reinvest it in our members and continue to drive our overall loyalty, member engagement, and drive top-line sales. So a little bit of a different approach for us than you probably hear from some of our peers and others.

#m3402 · 2025-09-25 · Gary Millerchip · STATED

These digital capabilities are also an enabler for retail media, as they allow us to target specific ads that deliver greater value for both members and suppliers, while always honoring the privacy choices of our members.

#m3412 · 2025-09-25 · Gary Millerchip · STATED

It's still very much in the early stages. You know, when we talk about alternative revenue for us, I think that it's broader than media.

TGT8 statements

Brian Cornell said Roundel was expected to grow in the high teens for full year 2024, on top of more than 20% growth in 2023. [m3542] Cara Sylvester set a target for Roundel to double its roughly $2 billion value over the next 5 years, expanding on Cornell's earlier growth commentary. [m3330, m3541, m3543] Rick Gomez set a goal to grow Target Plus GMV to $5 billion by 2030, and reported Q1 GMV growth of more than 20% with hundreds of new partners added. [m3677, m3678] Cornell reported Roundel and Target Plus both saw double digit growth in Q1 2025, showing continued momentum on both promises. [m3670]

Show the 8 verbatim statements
#m3541 · 2024-08-21 · Brian Cornell · STATED

Roundel continues to experience rapid growth, based on the joint value it creates for both our guests and our vendors.

#m3543 · 2024-08-21 · Brian Cornell · STATED

Beyond the direct benefit of guest engagement with the platform, Target Circle also helps us gain deep consumer insights, allowing us to extend more personal, customized offers through our Roundel advertising business.

#m3542 · 2024-08-21 · Brian Cornell · STATED · by full year

For the full year, Roundel is expected to grow in the high teens, on top of more than 20% growth in 2023.

#m3335 · 2025-03-04 · James Lee · STATED · by 2025 and beyond

Given recent trends and the increased focus on retail prime we've seen at the federal, state and local level, we expect to benefit from further shrink improvement in 2025 and beyond.

#m3330 · 2025-03-04 · Cara Sylvester · STATED · by next 5 years

At nearly $2 billion in value for Target, we see the potential for Roundel to double its size over the next 5 years.

#m3670 · 2025-05-21 · Brian Cornell · STATED

beyond the direct benefits of rising digital sales, they also fuel the growth of profitable services like Roundel, our retail ad business, and Target Plus, our third-party digital marketplace, both of which saw double digit growth in Q1.

#m3677 · 2025-05-21 · Rick Gomez · STATED · by by 2030

Another way we deliver newness and value is through our Target Plus marketplace, where we have set ambitious goals to grow GMV to $5 billion by 2030 by offering even more brands and products guests want and expect from Target.

#m3678 · 2025-05-21 · Rick Gomez · STATED

This quarter alone, we grew Target Plus GMV by more than 20%, adding hundreds of new partners to the platform, driving traffic, and increasing conversion online.

LOW1 statement

Bill Boltz stated Lowe's is rebranding its retail media network into a simpler platform to help brand partners meet marketing objectives like on shelf performance, new product launches, seasonal promotions, and multiproduct sales. [m3241]

Show the 1 verbatim statement
#m3241 · 2024-08-20 · Bill Boltz · STATED

Our marketing team is rebranding our retail media network program to a simpler platform where we help our brand partners meet a wide range of marketing objectives from performance on shelf and new product launches to seasonal promotions and multiproduct sales.

OPEN is an unresolved commitment on the clock; STATED is on the record without a checkable bar and is never counted or scored. Method: methodology.